I am going to try to catch up on my card pile since I do not have another potential trial until the end of November. I have a little bit of time.
1. Roman Anthony. Anthony is starting to appear a lot more in my trade offers. I suspect this has something to do with the fact that some of the prospect shine has worn off as a result of his inability to stay healthy thus far. I am not even remotely close to ready to call him a bust because he has hit so well when he's been healthy. They just need to figure out how to avoid these injuries.
2. Jarren Duran. Duran had one of the worst 20/20 seasons of all time. He had a .627 OPS and 76 OPS+. I just do not think there is any way he is going to be back in Boston next season. Hopefully they can find a reasonable trade for him.
3. Aroldis Chapman. Chapman continued to build on his Hall of Fame resume, eclipsing the 400 save mark and breaking the record for strikeouts as a reliever. He's likely not getting in first ballot, but I believe he will get in. He probably goes in with a Reds cap, but I always want Red Sox players in the Hall.
4. Kristian Campbell. Campbell had a nice season in the minors. Hopefully he can make that translate to success in the Majors next season, but I have no idea where he will play.
5. Pedro Martinez. I definitely like getting retired players in sets, but I would like to see Topps think outside the box a little bit more. We still get a lot of cards of guys like Pedro Martinez. Let's see Bruce Hurst or someone.
6. Garrett Crochet. Man, it was a mistake to bring Crochet into the last game of the postseason. Hopefully he will be healthy next season, though with the development of Payton Tolle, it is not as dire.
7. Roman Anthony.
1. Payton Tolle. Tolle is quickly becoming one of my favorite players. He had a great rookie season that could get him finishing third in the Rookie of the Year vote. He became one of the Red Sox best pitchers this year.
2. Jarren Duran.
3. Aroldis Chapman.
4. Roger Clemens. I don't know what it will take to get Clemens into the Hall of Fame at this point. I think something that could be done is to have a special committee formed to consider the Steroid Era one time and determine which players should get in, notwithstanding whether or not there is evidence that they used. Clemens still maintains his innocence, he never tested positive during his playing career. He is a player that absolutely should be in the Hall of Fame.
5. Franklin Arias. Arias is Boston's top prospect and will hopefully be in the big leagues next season.
6. Payton Tolle.
7. Carlton Fisk. Fisk was the A.L.'s first unanimous Rookie of the Year. He is also one of two Red Sox first-round picks to be named to the Hall of Fame. If Clemens ever gets in, there will be three.
8. Franklin Arias.
9. Connelly Early. I don't love the trade of Early for Curtis Mead. Especially since Mead had two at-bats before getting hurt. I don't expect Early to be an ace, but I think he will be better than Jake Bennett ultimately. He had been pretty good for Boston. Mead better be good next year.
10. Roman Anthony.
11. Walker Buehler. I really thought Buehler was going to have a good season in 2025. He was really bad though. He has gotten better since leaving Boston. I have no idea what went so wrong for him in Boston.
12. David Ortiz. Another player like Martinez who appears a lot in sets. I never complain about getting cards of Ortiz though.
13. Jim Rice. Rice is the other first-round pick of the Red Sox to make the Hall of Fame. I've been interested in first-round draft picks lately after some arguments on Twitter.
14. Nomar Garciaparra. Garciaparra is another first-round pick by the Red Sox. I have not given up on the chance that he could make it in the Hall. He had a very high peak.
15. Franklin Arias.
16. Kristian Campbell.
17. Roman Anthony. This is the kind of card that I would not have gotten in a trade at this time last year. This is how much Anthony's stock has fallen lately.
18. Manny Ramirez. Ramirez is another player I think should be in, PED suspensions be damned. I just don't think that PED use should disqualify a player from the Hall. Especially in a case like Ramirez's, who wasn't caught until he was well past his prime.
19. Jim Rice.
20. Isaiah Campbell. I was disappointed Campbell was not a better pitcher than he was. He seemed like someone with some good stuff, but he could not harness it.
21. Masataka Yoshida. Yoshida, like Duran, is a player I could see Boston moving this offseason. I don't expect a big return, but I don't think he will be in Boston in 2027. I like him, but things did not really work out for him.
22. Trevor Story. Story is also in the category with Duran and Yoshida. The Red Sox need to find a way to get more flexibility into the lineup and Duran, Story and Yoshida handcuff the team somewhat. Story was great in 2025, but that has been the only successful season since he signed a big free agent deal.
23. Jarren Duran.
24. Jarren Duran.
25. Jarren Duran.
26. Bobby Dalbec. It's strange to look at Dalbec's first two seasons in Boston when he had an .819 OPS and 114 OPS+ and slugged 33 homers in 156 games. He dropped off severely. There was always a lot of swing-and-miss in his game, but it got out of hand.


























