Tuesday, November 17, 2026

2027 Contemporary Ballot Announced (Managers and Executives)

I will be pretty honest, I am not that interested in this particular ballot.  At all.  It's sort of hard for me to get all that worked up about the managers and executives in the first place, I really don't care much about the Manager of the Year Award either.  When none of the candidates have any ties to the Red Sox, it's even harder.  At some point, Terry Francona and Theo Epstein will be up, and I might care a little bit more then.  

There are eight candidates on the ballot.  Of the eight candidates, four had Major League careers, three of whom were actually quite good.  I will talk about all of that when discussing each candidate.  There are 16 voters on the committee and each voter gets three votes.

SANDY ALDERSON

CREDENTIALS:  General Manager of Oakland Athletics (1983-1997) and New York Mets (2011-2018); Chief Executive Officer of the San Diego Padres (2005-2009); President of the New York Mets (2021-2023).

ACHIEVEMENTS:  1989 Oakland Athletics World Championship, Executive of the Year (2015)

Alderson built the Oakland Athletics into a mini dynasty in the late 1980's through the early 1990's, but he was also in charge when the team declined.  He also ran the Mets when they made it to the World Series in 2015.

WOULD I VOTE FOR HIM?  Eh, not really sure.  I would want to do some more research.

WILL HE GET ELECTED THIS YEAR?  I am going with no.  He had a distinguished career, but I am not sure it stands out too much from other general managers.


DUSTY BAKER

CREDENTIALS:  Outfielder for the Atlanta Braves (1968-1975), Los Angeles Dodgers (1976-1983), San Francisco Giants (1984) and Oakland Athletics (1985-1986); Manager for the San Francisco Giants (1993-2002), Chicago Cubs (2003-2006), Cincinnati Reds (2008-2013), Washington Nationals (2016-2017) and Houston Astros (2020-2023).

ACHIEVEMENTS:  All Star (1981, 1982), Gold Glove (1981), Silver Slugger (1980, 1981), Manager of the Year (1993, 1997, 2000).  World Champion as Manager (2022).

Baker probably has the most distinguished playing career of any of the players on this ballot.  He was a legitimately good player who hit .278/.347/.432 with 1,981 hits, 242 home runs and 1,013 RBIs.  He had a managerial record of 2,183-1,862 and won three pennants.

WOULD I VOTE FOR HIM?  Probably.

WILL HE GET ELECTED THIS YEAR?  I am predicting Baker will get elected this year.

IF ELECTED, CAP WILL BE?  Giants


BRUCE BOCHY

CREDENTIALS:  Catcher for the Houston Astros (1978-1980), New York Mets (1982) and San Diego Padres (1983-1987); Manager for the San Diego Padres (1995-2006), San Francisco Giants (2007-2019) and Texas Rangers (2023-2025).

ACHIEVEMENTS:  Manager of the Year (1996).  World Champion as Manager (2010, 2012, 2014, 2023).

Bochy is the most accomplished manager on the ballot, winning four World Championships and an additional pennant.  His career record of 2,252-2,266 does not look all that impressive but it is hurt by managing a bunch of mediocre Padres teams.  His playing career does not add anything to his resume as he was mostly a backup catcher.

WOULD I VOTE FOR HIM?  Yes

WILL HE GET ELECTED THIS YEAR?  I am predicting Bochy gets elected this year.

IF ELECTED, CAP WILL BE?  Giants


JOE MADDON

CREDENTIALS:  Manager of the California/Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels (1996, 1999, 2020-2022), Tampa Bay Rays (2006-2014), Chicago Cubs (2015-2019).

ACHIEVEMENTS:  Manager of the Year (2008, 2011, 2015).  World Champion as Manager (2016).

Maddon is given a lot of credit for helping turn around the Rays and building them into a contender and for bringing home the Cubs first World Championship since 1908.  He had a career record of 1,382-1,216 and won an additional pennant in 2008 with the Rays.

WOULD I VOTE FOR HIM?  Probably not.

WILL HE GET ELECTED THIS YEAR?  I am going with no just because it would be very difficult to have three people elected and this is a stacked ballot.  

IF ELECTED, CAP WILL BE?  Cubs 


LOU PINIELLA

CREDENTIALS:  Outfielder for the Baltimore Orioles (1964), Cleveland Indians (1968), Kansas City Royals (1969-1973), New York Yankees (1974-1984).  Manager for the New York Yankees (1986-1987, 1988), Cincinnati Reds (1990-1992), Seattle Mariners (1993-2002), Tampa Bay Devil Rays (2003-2005) and Chicago Cubs (2007-2010).

ACHIVEMENTS:  Rookie of the Year (1969), All Star (1972), Manager of the Year (1995, 2001, 2008).  World Champion as Manager (1990).

Piniella was a good player, but not a great one.  He hit .291/.333/.409 with 102 home runs and 766 RBIs.  He won a World Championship with the Reds and then managed the Mariners through the best stretch of their history.  He managed the Devil Rays and Cubs just prior to them becoming great teams.  He had a 1,835-1,713 record.

WOULD I VOTE FOR HIM?  I would seriously consider it.

WILL HE GET ELECTED THIS YEAR?  I kind of doubt it.

IF ELECTED, CAP WOULD BE?  Mariners


BRIAN SABEAN

CREDENTIALS:  General Manager of the San Francisco Giants (1997-2014); Executive for the New York Yankees (2023-2026).

ACHIVEMENTS:  San Francisco Giants World Champions (2010, 2012, 2014), Executive of the Year (2003).

Sabean was the chief architect of the Giants becoming a sort-of dynasty that won the World Series three times in five years.  

WOULD I VOTE FOR HIM?  Maybe?

WILL HE GET ELECTED THIS YEAR?  I think he stands the best chance of any of the non-managers, but I am going to guess he misses slightly.


TED TURNER

CREDENTIALS:  Manager of the Atlanta Braves (1977), Owner of the Atlanta Braves.

ACHIEVEMENTS:  Atlanta Braves World Champions (1995).

Turner was a media mogul who owned TBS and CNN, as well as the Braves.  He was the owner of the team when it became a nationally known team, thanks to being one of the superstation teams, and owned the team throughout the 1990's, a period of dominance during which the Braves went to the World Series five times and won once.

WOULD I VOTE FOR HIM?  No.

WILL HE BE ELECTED THIS YEAR?  I am guessing no.


BILL WHITE

CREDENTIALS:  First baseman/outfielder for the New York/San Francisco Giants (1956, 1958), St. Louis Cardinals (1959-1965, 1969) and Philadelphia Phillies (1966-1968).  National League President (1989-1994).

ACHIEVEMENTS:  All Star (1959-1961, 1963-1964), Gold Glove (1960-1966).

I will be honest, I did not know White was as good of a player as he was.  He hit .286/.351/.455 with 202 home runs and 870 RBIs and won seven Gold Gloves.  It's hard for me to say much about his tenure as NL President because honestly, I don't really know what league presidents do.

WOULD I VOTE FOR HIM?  Probably not.  Good career as a player and the NL President thing is interesting, but like I said, I don't really know what that means.

WILL HE GET ELECTED THIS YEAR?  I am going with no.


FINAL PREDICTIONS:

I think it will be Bochy and Baker getting elected, if there is a third one, I think Sabean gets in.  It is nearly impossible based on the voting setup for more than three candidates to be elected.  

No comments:

Post a Comment